Can a member who is not a manager or holds a small stake inspect the accounts?
The company’s manager (müdür) refuses to disclose sales revenue, bank transactions or debts despite a member’s questions. At the general meeting, members are merely told that the company is making a loss. A member need not accept this explanation as sufficient. Members may question the company’s accounts even if they are not managers or hold only a small share of its capital. This right allows members who are not involved in day-to-day management, in particular, to establish the company’s actual position.
Article 614 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (TTK) grants every member the right to obtain information and conduct inspections on specific matters. Members need neither a majority stake nor the support of other members to exercise this right. Nor must they first prove an irregularity or loss. Access to information enables members both to investigate concerns and to exercise their membership rights on an informed basis.
An independent audit of the company does not remove this right. Members also need not wait until the ordinary general meeting to request information. These explanations concern members of limited liability companies. The procedure for obtaining information and conducting inspections differs in joint stock companies (anonim şirket). The company’s legal form should therefore be checked before deciding which procedure to follow.
What information and documents may a member request?
The right to information concerns the company’s affairs and accounts. A member may ask about income, expenditure, loan liabilities, significant contracts and litigation involving the company. Members may also seek to establish the basis for payments made by the company to other members or managers. The balance sheet and income statement are often the starting point for an inspection. However, providing only these statements may not answer every specific question.
An inspection request should clearly identify its subject matter and the relevant period. For example, a member seeking to examine payments to a manager during a particular period may request access to accounting entries, payment documents and the relevant resolutions. When investigating the price received for a particular sale, the contract, invoice and record of receipt are relevant together. Framing the request in this way shows which record will answer which question and defines the scope of the dispute.
The right of inspection does not authorise a member to remove all original documents from the company’s premises. Requests for copies or electronic versions must be assessed in light of the need for an effective inspection and the duty of confidentiality. Members may also explain in their request why they need specialist assistance to understand the financial records. Requesting details of bank transactions from the company is distinct from requesting banking passwords or authority to operate the account.
How should an information request be submitted to the company?
The initial request is addressed to the company’s managers. Article 614 of the TTK does not require a formal notice sent through a notary (noter ihtarnamesi). Nevertheless, a written request makes it easier to prove its scope and the date it reached the company. The company’s registered name, the manager to whom the request is addressed and the applicant’s status as a member must be stated correctly. A notice sent through a notary may be used for this purpose, but it does not by itself establish that the request is justified or that all procedural steps have been completed.
The request may set out separately the questions to be answered and the records to be inspected. It should specify the relevant period and subject matter, and ask for a suitable inspection date. The company’s response should also be retained. Creating a written record after oral discussions reduces the risk of having to rely solely on the parties’ conflicting accounts later. The file should contain both the request and evidence of its delivery.
The law does not prescribe a fixed number of days for responding to this initial request. A reasonable period should be allowed, taking account of the scope of the records requested. Any deadline stated in the request is set by the member and should not be presented as a statutory deadline. If the company discloses some documents but withholds others, the outstanding requests should be identified separately. A partial response does not mean that all questions have been answered.
Can inspection be restricted on grounds of company confidentiality?
Managers may restrict inspection to the extent necessary if there is a risk that the information will be used to the company’s detriment. This power does not permit them to withhold all accounts merely because the members disagree. The grounds for restriction must relate to the information requested and the alleged risk. The company interest requiring protection and whether a narrower measure would suffice must also be assessed.
Members must also protect any company secrets they learn. Under Article 613 of the TTK, this duty cannot be removed by the articles of association or a general meeting resolution. The right to information does not permit unrestricted disclosure of commercial information to third parties. Where a member is engaged in another activity in the same sector, the information request must be assessed together with the specific risk of harm and the duty of loyalty. Restrictions of the same scope cannot be justified in every case.
The judgment of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) dated 29.01.2026, case no. 2025/3395 and decision no. 2026/572, illustrates this limit. The Chamber considered a general meeting resolution restricting inspection of the company’s official books and records. It upheld the judgment declaring that resolution null and void because it infringed the right to information. This assessment shows that even a majority at the general meeting cannot restrict the right beyond the limits permitted by law.
Can a member go directly to court if the manager refuses access to records?
The statutory sequence is to apply first to the managers, then to the general meeting if access is denied, and subsequently to the court. Following a manager’s refusal, the member must, as a rule, ask the general meeting to decide the matter. Bringing proceedings directly on the strength of a notice sent only to the manager may raise issues concerning the procedural prerequisites. The information request and the application to the general meeting should therefore be treated as separate steps.
The member should submit the manager’s response to the general meeting and identify the information that remains unavailable. Recording the request clearly in the meeting minutes establishes what the meeting approved or rejected. The mere fact that a general meeting took place does not mean that it decided the information request. The minutes should show whether the request was actually considered and the scope of any inspection permitted.
If the general meeting does not convene or fails to consider the request, the procedure requires separate assessment. The procedures for convening a general meeting and seeking court authorisation to convene it have their own requirements. The fact that every member has a right to information does not mean that all procedures for convening a meeting are unconditional. Where both the managers and the general meeting remain silent, the steps taken and the actual obstruction must be considered together.
Which court has jurisdiction, and is mediation required?
If the general meeting unjustifiably prevents access to information or inspection, the member may seek a court order. The application is brought against the company as a legal entity before the commercial court of first instance (asliye ticaret mahkemesi) where the company has its registered office. The court considers the applicant’s membership status, previous requests, the scope of the request and the reasons for denying access. The statement of claim should clearly identify the matters on which information is sought or the records to be inspected.
A claim confined to the right to information and inspection does not seek payment of a sum of money. It is therefore not subject to mandatory mediation as a prerequisite to proceedings under Article 5/A of the TTK. If a monetary claim or compensation is also sought in the same dispute, the mediation requirement for that claim must be assessed separately. It is incorrect to assume that all commercial disputes are subject to the same mediation rule.
A court decision on the right to information and inspection under Article 614/3 of the TTK is final. This finality does not, however, extend to every dispute between members or every action challenging a general meeting resolution. The legal relief sought in the statement of claim must therefore be identified correctly. An order requiring information to be provided does not, by itself, amount to an award of compensation or an order for payment of a dividend.
Which documents should be prepared before bringing proceedings?
Records establishing membership status, the articles of association, information requests and proof of delivery should be assembled. The file should also contain the managers’ responses, the application to the general meeting and the meeting minutes. If an inspection date was set but the records were not made available, the way this was documented should be explained. These documents establish which right was obstructed and how, beyond a general disagreement.
The judgment of the 11th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated 25.03.2025, case no. 2024/3219 and decision no. 2025/2088, also considered the procedural steps taken. In that case, which also involved a request for the manager’s removal, it had not been shown that an application for information had been made to the general meeting and subsequently to the court. The Chamber upheld the judgment dismissing the claims, which included this assessment. The requirements for protecting the right to information and for removing a manager must be assessed separately.
If inspection reveals unexplained payments or other unlawful conduct, the related claims must be considered separately. An information request does not automatically suspend the time limits for other proceedings. Matters such as challenging a general meeting resolution or pursuing a manager’s liability have their own requirements. Members seeking access to information should therefore also assess existing resolutions and the applicable time limits for challenging them.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a member with a small stake in a limited liability company request information?
Yes. Every member has the right to obtain information and conduct inspections on specific matters. Exercising this right does not require a majority stake or the support of other members.
Does the manager satisfy the request merely by providing the balance sheet?
Not always. If the balance sheet does not answer the member’s questions about specific transactions, the relevant explanations and records must also be considered. The response must be assessed against the scope of the request.
Must an information request be sent through a notary?
Article 614 of the TTK imposes no such requirement. However, a written request and proof of delivery make it easier to establish the content of the request and that it reached the company.
Can a member access the company’s bank account directly?
Membership alone does not confer a right to banking passwords, access to the account or authority to operate it. A member may request information on the company’s bank transactions and the related records from the company’s managers.