Can a parent transfer their home to one of their children?

Someone who learns that their father has transferred his home to their sibling may believe they have lost their entire inheritance share. A sale recorded in the land register may also suggest that nothing can be done. However, the outcome depends on the transaction's true purpose, rather than its description. A parent may sell or give away their own immovable property during their lifetime. Certain transfers may nevertheless become the subject of litigation between heirs after the parent's death.

Children's expectations of a future inheritance do not require a parent to obtain their consent to every transaction. However, a sale that actually conceals a gift requires a different assessment. If the purpose is also to deprive heirs of their inheritance rights, the transfer may constitute a sham transaction by the deceased (muris muvazaası). Where a gift is made openly, the rules on reserved shares (saklı pay) and reduction may apply. These two remedies have different requirements and consequences.

When does a transfer amount to depriving heirs of their inheritance?

A sham transaction by the deceased occurs when a person presents the transfer of registered immovable property as a sale, although they actually intend a gift, in order to deprive an heir of their inheritance rights. The deceased is the person whose estate passes to the heirs. In this situation, the parties genuinely intend to transfer the home. However, they conceal the gratuitous nature of the transfer and make it appear to be a sale. The court investigates whether such an arrangement lies behind the contract recorded in the land register.

Article 19 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK) requires contracts to be assessed according to the parties' true and common intention. Article 706 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK) requires contracts intended to transfer immovable property to be executed in official form. In a sham transaction by the deceased, the apparent sale does not reflect the parties' true intention. The concealed gift also fails to satisfy the required form. If the necessary elements are proved, an heir may seek cancellation of the title entry and registration in their own name in proportion to their inheritance share.

Not every sale at a low price or transfer to one child falls within this category. A genuine sale does not automatically become invalid because the other children were not given assets of equal value. A sense of unfairness within the family is also insufficient on its own. The claimant must provide concrete evidence that the apparent sale concealed a gift and was intended to deprive heirs of their inheritance rights. Where a sale is genuine, subsequent failure to pay the price does not, by itself, establish a concealed gift. It may instead give rise to a separate dispute concerning the seller's payment claim.

Can a claim be brought while the father is alive, and must all siblings participate?

Under Article 575 of the TMK, succession opens on death. A child therefore cannot bring a claim based on a sham transaction by the deceased while their father or mother is alive solely by relying on a future inheritance entitlement. A transaction entered into by a living person may be invalid on other grounds. However, the requirements for grounds such as lack of legal capacity or defects in consent, and who may bring such claims, must be assessed separately. Being a prospective heir does not, by itself, confer standing to bring these claims.

After the parent's death, heirs whose inheritance rights have been infringed may rely on a sham transaction by the deceased. This right is not confined to heirs entitled to a reserved share. An heir may bring a claim independently in respect of their own inheritance share. Other siblings' unwillingness to participate does not prevent this. However, if the claim seeks the return of the entire property to the estate, the required participation of the parties must be considered separately.

How does the court determine whether the sale was genuine?

The burden of proof rests on the heir alleging that the transaction was a sham. The court considers whether there was a reasonable explanation for the deceased's decision to sell. It examines the buyer's ability to pay at the date of transfer and whether the purchase price was actually paid. The price recorded in the land register is compared with the property's actual value at the date of transfer. Family relationships, benefits conferred on the other children and the assets remaining in the estate are also assessed together.

Because the heir was not a party to the contract, they may also prove their case through witness evidence. Bank transactions, payment documents and income records from the time of the transfer may assist the investigation. A witness's account of family disagreements alone may be insufficient. The court assesses the witness's specific knowledge of the reason for the transfer, the absence of payment or the parties' true agreement. Who occupied the home after the sale also takes on significance when considered alongside the other evidence.

In its judgment dated 26.02.2025, case no. 2023/368 and judgment no. 2025/87, the General Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay Hukuk Genel Kurulu) emphasised that the evidence must be assessed as a whole. The majority required concrete facts establishing an intention to deprive heirs of their inheritance rights. The financial circumstances of the children who acquired the property were not considered in isolation from the other evidence. The existence of other assets left by the deceased does not, by itself, rule out a sham transaction. The assessment depends on the circumstances as a whole, rather than a single indicator.

What if the land register records a gift or a lifetime care agreement (ölünceye kadar bakma sözleşmesi)?

If the transaction is expressly recorded as a gift in the land register, there is no gift disguised as a sale. The mere fact that a gift was made therefore does not establish a sham transaction by the deceased. However, a valid gift does not eliminate all inheritance claims. An heir whose reserved share has been infringed may seek reduction if the requirements under Articles 560 and 565 of the TMK are met. A reserved share is the portion of an inheritance that the law protects for certain heirs.

A reduction claim does not invariably result in the return of the entire home. Its purpose is to make good the shortfall in the reserved share. This requires an assessment of the estate, debts, other benefits conferred and the value received by the heir. The fact that the land register records a gift does not, by itself, mean the claim will succeed. For example, when examining the transfer of a single home, the other assets left by the deceased must also be taken into account. The reserved share cannot be calculated solely by reference to the value of the transferred home.

A lifetime care agreement does not automatically amount to an attempt to deprive heirs of their inheritance rights. The deceased may genuinely have transferred the home in return for care. However, if the apparent care arrangement concealed a gift, a sham transaction by the deceased may be alleged. The true purpose of the agreement and the scope of the care obligation are examined. Subsequent shortcomings in care do not necessarily establish that the transaction was a sham from the outset. Claims arising from a breach of the care obligation are distinct from an heir's allegation of a sham transaction.

Is the right to sue lost if the sibling sells the home to someone else?

A subsequent transfer of the property to someone else does not automatically extinguish all claims. However, the new owner's position may affect the outcome. Article 1023 of the TMK protects a third party who acquires ownership in good faith in reliance on the land register. Article 1024 of the TMK provides that a person who knows or ought to know that the registration is unlawful cannot benefit from this protection. The chain of transfers, the prices paid and the transferees' knowledge are therefore examined.

In its judgment dated 26.03.2026, case no. 2025/4734 and judgment no. 2026/2319, Civil Chamber No. 1 of the Court of Cassation considered transfers made through intermediate owners. The Chamber upheld the finding that a sham transaction by the deceased had been proved. The judgment shows that the involvement of intermediate owners does not, by itself, bar the claim. Where title cannot be recovered because of an acquisition in good faith, claims for the property's monetary value or compensation are examined separately. The legal basis of these claims and the persons against whom they may be brought depend on the circumstances.

Can a claim be brought years after the transfer?

As a rule, a claim for cancellation of title and registration based on a sham transaction by the deceased is subject to neither a limitation period nor a time limit extinguishing the right to sue (hak düşürücü süre). The fact that the transfer took place long ago does not, by itself, extinguish the right to bring a claim. The General Assembly of Civil Chambers of the Court of Cassation reiterated this rule in its judgment dated 28.05.2025, case no. 2023/493 and judgment no. 2025/356. Nevertheless, the claimant must still prove the sham transaction despite the passage of time.

Different time limits apply to reduction claims. Under Article 571 of the TMK, the right to sue must be exercised within one year of learning that the reserved share has been infringed. For transfers made during the deceased's lifetime, the ultimate time limit is ten years from the opening of succession. The starting points for these periods cannot be determined solely by reference to the date on which the title transfer became known. The date succession opened and the date the infringement of the reserved share became known must be examined together.

It is therefore necessary to identify the correct type of claim. The absence of a time limit for claims based on a sham transaction by the deceased cannot automatically be applied to a reduction claim or a separate claim for the property's monetary value. Witnesses and payment records may also become harder to locate as time passes. Investigating the transfer history early helps clarify which claims can be pursued and what evidence supports them. The possibility of a further transfer may also give rise to a need for interim legal protection.

Where should the claim be filed, and which documents are needed?

A claim for cancellation of title and registration based on a sham transaction by the deceased is brought before the Civil Court of First Instance (asliye hukuk mahkemesi) where the property is located. Articles 2 and 12 of the Turkish Code of Civil Procedure (HMK) set out the basic rules on subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction. This rule on location applies to a claim for cancellation of title based on a sham transaction by the deceased. Territorial jurisdiction for a reduction claim must be assessed separately. As a rule, a claim for cancellation of title is brought against the current registered owner. If there have been subsequent transfers or a claim for the property's monetary value is pursued, the transactions must be examined separately to identify the correct defendants.

The certificate of inheritance, current land register entry and official deeds for previous transfers are the first documents to examine. Relying solely on family accounts without establishing the transfer dates, transaction types and parties may leave important gaps. Payment documents and the events known to each witness must also be identified. Where a person cannot obtain records directly, they may ask the court to order their production. The request must relate to specific events and records.

This claim for cancellation of title is not subject to mandatory mediation merely because it concerns inheritance. A dispute over the termination of co-ownership under Article 18/B of the Turkish Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes is a different matter. Filing a claim also does not automatically prevent a further sale of the home. Interim measures (ihtiyati tedbir) may be requested if the requirements under Article 389 and the following provisions of the HMK are met. The court assesses the facts indicating that the right is at risk and the evidence submitted; it may also require security where necessary.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an heir still bring a claim if the land register records a sale?

Yes. A claim based on a sham transaction by the deceased may be brought if it can be proved that the sale actually concealed a gift and was intended to deprive heirs of their inheritance rights. The type of transaction recorded in the land register does not, by itself, determine the outcome.

Is my signature required when my father transfers the home to my sibling?

A parent does not need their children's consent to transfer property owned solely by that parent merely because the children expect a future inheritance. Whether the transfer may later be challenged is a separate question.

Does the absence of a bank payment receipt necessarily mean the sale was a sham?

No. The absence of a payment receipt does not, by itself, prove a concealed gift. The method of payment, the buyer's financial means, the parties' true agreement and the other evidence are assessed together.

Can an heir bring a claim alone if the other siblings do not wish to sue?

After the parent's death, an heir whose inheritance rights have been infringed may seek cancellation of title and registration in proportion to their own inheritance share. All siblings do not need to participate in this claim.

This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. The appropriate legal remedy and the outcome will depend on the circumstances and evidence in each case.
Author
Av. Mustafa Salih Koçer

Antalya Bar Association · Mengi & Koçer Law Firm